Best Milani Lip Pencil | Radio WGN 720

Which Milani lip liner is the best?

Applying a coat of lipstick is not enough to achieve the most well-groomed and long-lasting lips. For this you will need a lip liner. Lip liners help accentuate and define the edges of your lips, and extra makeup helps keep your favorite ultra-creamy lipstick from spilling all over the place.

The best Milani lip liner is the Milani Easyliner Retractable Lip Pencil. It’s double ended and the retractable tip means there’s no sharpening like a pencil.

What to know before buying a Milani lip liner

Lip liner look

Milani lip liners are typically used to create a classic look or add definition to a more modern style.

  • Classic Use a lip liner shade that matches your lipstick as closely as possible to make your lipstick last longer. You can apply your lip liner before the lipstick to highlight your look or adjust your lipstick application afterwards.
  • Modern Use a lip liner to add definition to your lips. This is usually done by using lip liner shades that are noticeably darker or lighter than your lipstick to make your lips pop. There are also many other techniques and styles to choose from.

To finish

Milani lip liners are available in many finishes, but cream and matte are the most common. All other finishes are a mix of these two.

  • Cream the finishes are, of course, creamy. Many shimmer a little or a lot in the light, depending on the formula. These finishes often contain oils that help moisturize your lips but also make the liner easy to apply and short-lasting.
  • Mast finishes are flat in appearance with no reflectivity. They also tend to be dry which means they won’t stain easily and will last for several hours.

What to Look for in a Quality Milani Lip Pencil

Wearing time

Milani lip liners help your look last longer throughout the day and last for at least several hours. The average wearing time is 4 to 6 hours. Some lip liners last an entire day, and these will clearly be marketed as such, although Milani may use different terminology to describe the capacity.


Milani lip liners use retractable pencils or barrels.

  • Pencil liners should be sharpened with each use. This can lead to wasted products, but it also gives you the flexibility to adjust your tip size at will.
  • retractable liners have a predetermined, usually fine tip that is twisted up or down to access the cream. The liner may fall out of the tube, especially when there is little liner left.

How much you can expect to spend on a Milani lip liner

Milani is a budget brand and their lip liners tend to cost $10 or less. That said, some storefronts may charge more, especially for hard-to-find or discontinued shades.

Milani Lip Liner FAQ

Does my Milani lip liner need to match my lipstick perfectly for a classic look?

A. Not necessarily, although you should use as close a shade as possible. If it’s a tiny bit different, you might be able to mix your lip liner and lipstick together so the difference doesn’t stand out. You can also use translucent lip liners to help your lipstick last without affecting your classic look.

How can I properly line my lips so they don’t look so aggressive?

A. There are a few techniques you can use. The first is to use only a matching lip liner. The second is to line first with a nude colored liner before adding a line of color. Finally, you can only highlight certain sections of your lips if necessary.

Can I use a Milani lip liner on its own?

A. Yes. This is actually a common technique used by those who dislike the maintenance and careful application requirements of lipstick. There are a few styles that you can shoot using just the lip liner. The easiest way is to line your natural lips with a lighter or darker lip liner to make them stand out. You can also coat your entire lips like you would lipstick. Some people like to apply a layer of translucent gloss to these styles to add a bit more wow, although technically this isn’t using lip liner alone.

What is the best Milani lip liner to buy?

Top Milani lip liner

Milani Easyliner Retractable Lip Pencil

What do you want to know: This lip liner is easy to use and store and features an ultra-fine tip for precise application.

What you will love: The tip is retractable to prevent drying out and make it easier to access more product. It is creamy enough to apply smoothly without dripping. It is double ended and includes a professional brush. It’s made in the USA, vegan, and not tested on animals.

What you should consider: It is only available in two shades: sweet plum and the most natural. Some consumers have had issues with drying out. Others felt it didn’t last as long as it should have.

Or buy: Sold by Amazon and Ulta Beauty

Best Milani Lip Pencil for the Money

Milani Color Statement Lip Pencil

Milani Color Statement Lip Pencil

What do you want to know: This classic pencil design comes in eight shades, including several reds and browns, with matte finishes.

What you will love: The tip can be sharpened precisely to your preferred size. It is not tested on animals. It glides on smoothly and does not clump. It mixes well with other products, like glosses.

What you should consider: It is marketed as long-wearing but only lasts four hours before needing a touch-up. Some consumers have had issues with the tip breaking off when sharpening.

Or buy: Sold by Amazon and Ulta Beauty

Worth checking out

Milani Anti-Feather Lip Pencil

Milani Anti-Feather Lip Pencil

What do you want to know: This choice is good for preventing smudging without affecting appearance.

What you will love: It’s sheer, so you get all the functional benefits of a lip liner without affecting your finished look. It is enriched with vitamins and hydration to improve the health of your lips. It is not tested on animals.

What you should consider: Some consumers have had difficulty sharpening the tip properly, reporting that it breaks easily. Others received dried pencils.

Or buy: Sold by Amazon

Register hereto receive the weekly BestReviews newsletter for helpful tips on new products and great deals.

Jordan C. Woikawritten for BestReviews. BestReviews has helped millions of consumers simplify their buying decisions, saving them time and money.

Copyright 2022 BestReviews, a Nexstar company. All rights reserved.